Home / For advisors / Guides / Buying leads in Canada
How to buy insurance leads in Canada: 10 questions to ask any lead vendor
The 10 questions
1. Is every lead exclusive to me, in writing?
“Exclusive” should mean one advisor, for the life of the lead. Get it in your agreement, including whether the lead will ever be resold later as an aged lead.
2. Where does the traffic come from?
You don’t need a vendor’s secret sauce, but you should know the type of source and whether people are actively looking for coverage. Ask how they keep out incentive traffic, such as people filling forms for a prize.
3. Who did the client agree to hear from?
Under CASL, you need consent before sending commercial texts and emails, and every message must identify you and include an unsubscribe. Ask to see the exact consent wording and confirm it names you or covers you clearly. Consent recorded with a time stamp is a good sign.
4. Is the phone number verified?
A verified number is the cheapest filter against fakes and typos. Ask whether the client verified their phone number before the lead was sent to you, not after.
5. What will I know before I call?
A name and number isn’t a lead. Look for what they want to protect, age range, family situation, income range, timing and monthly budget. That’s what lets you open with the right product, whether that’s term life, disability, critical illness or a living benefits package.
6. Are leads limited to my licensed provinces?
Licences are provincial. Every lead from a province you can’t write in is money spent on nothing. Ask how the vendor enforces this.
7. Real time or aged?
Real-time leads arrive the moment someone applies. Aged leads are older requests resold at a discount. Both exist; just know which one you’re paying for.
8. What’s the replacement policy?
Ask what counts as a bad lead (fake, duplicate, wrong number, out of province) and how fast it’s replaced. Get it in writing.
9. What if volume falls short?
If you buy a monthly package, ask what happens if they don’t deliver the full number: does delivery continue, or are you credited?
10. Who owns the client?
You should own the relationship. The vendor shouldn’t contact your clients about other products or sell their information on.
Red flags
- No written exclusivity, or “exclusive for 30 days”.
- Consent that only mentions “partners” or “third parties”.
- No phone verification, and no replacement policy.
- They won’t show you the page the client filled out.
- Leads from provinces where you aren’t licensed.
- Prices that look too good, often a sign of aged or recycled leads.
How many leads do you actually need?
Work backwards from the policies you want to place each month:
Leads needed = policies you want ÷ (contact rate × appointment rate × placement rate)
For example, with illustrative rates of 70% contact, 50% of contacts booking an appointment and 30% of appointments placing a policy, each lead has about a 10.5% chance of becoming a placed policy. To place 6 policies a month, you’d need about 57 leads. Use your own numbers once you’ve tracked a full month.
Getting the most from your first month
- Call every new lead within 5 minutes. See how fast to call an insurance lead.
- Book a needs analysis on the first call instead of quoting over the phone.
- Work every lead for at least 7 days before calling it dead.
- Track contact, appointment, app and placement rates every week.
Frequently asked questions
Is it legal to buy insurance leads in Canada?
Yes. Buying leads is common. What matters is that clients consented to be contacted, that your texts and emails meet CASL requirements, that personal information is handled under Canadian privacy law, and that you only write business where you’re licensed.
What should an insurance lead include?
At minimum: a verified phone number, email, province, what they want to protect, age range, timing and monthly budget, plus a record of their consent to be contacted.
How many insurance leads should I buy per month?
Work backwards from the policies you want to place. Divide your target by your contact rate, appointment rate and placement rate. Many solo advisors start around 60 a month, and teams buy more.
How do I know if a lead vendor is legitimate?
Ask for written exclusivity, the consent wording, a sample of the client-facing page, the replacement policy and how they limit leads to your licensed provinces. A legitimate vendor answers all of these clearly.
Want leads that pass every one of these checks?
Exclusive to you, screened for income and intent, contact verified and consented.
Apply to partner See a live client portal