Home / For advisors / Guides / Exclusive vs shared leads

Exclusive vs shared insurance leads in Canada: which one actually places more business?

By the North Advisor Group team. Updated . 4 minute read.

Short answer: A shared lead is sold to several advisors at once, so you race other advisors to the same person. An exclusive lead goes to one advisor only. Shared leads cost less each, but what pays your bills is cost per placed policy, and that usually favours exclusive leads for advisors who call fast and run a proper needs analysis. In Canada, also confirm the lead is from a province where you’re licensed and that the person consented to hear from you.

What is a shared insurance lead?

A shared lead is one person’s request for coverage sold to several advisors, often three to five, at the same time. Everyone gets the same name and number within seconds. The person then gets a wave of calls from advisors they’ve never heard of, and usually talks to whoever reaches them first.

Shared leads are typically generated on generic comparison or quote sites. The person agreed to be contacted by “partners”, not by you, which matters for both conversion and consent.

What is an exclusive insurance lead?

An exclusive lead goes to one advisor only and is never resold or recycled. The best exclusive leads go further: the person applies to a named advisor, on a page with that advisor’s photo and name, and consents to that advisor’s call. When you dial, you’re the advisor they chose, not one of five strangers.

Exclusive vs shared at a glance

Shared leadExclusive lead
Who else gets itSeveral advisors at onceOnly you
Your first callA race. The client may already be talking to someoneNo competition. You set the pace
Who they agreed to hear fromOften “partners” of a quote siteYou, by name, when done properly
Price per leadLowerHigher
What drives your returnSpeed and dial volumeSpeed plus a good needs analysis
Best forLarge call teams built for volumeAdvisors building a book and referrals

Why cost per lead is the wrong number

Price per lead is easy to compare and almost meaningless on its own. The number that matters is cost per placed policy: what you spent on leads divided by the policies that actually went in force.

Here’s a simple way to compare two programs. The numbers below are illustrative, not anyone’s pricing:

Program A (shared)Program B (exclusive)
Leads bought10060
Spend$1,500$3,000
Policies placed38
Cost per placed policy$500$375

Run your own numbers for a full month on each program before you decide. Track contact rate, appointments set, apps submitted and policies placed, not just leads received.

Two Canadian checks before you buy any lead

1. Is the client in a province where you’re licensed?

Insurance agents are licensed provincially, and you can only write business where you hold a licence. A lead from a province you aren’t licensed in is a lead you can’t place. Ask any vendor how they limit leads to your provinces. Your regulator’s site, listed through the Canadian Council of Insurance Regulators, has the rules for your licence.

2. Who did the client agree to hear from?

Canada’s Anti-Spam Legislation (CASL) requires consent before you send commercial texts or emails, along with your identification and a working unsubscribe. A form that says “partners may contact you” is weaker than consent to hear from you by name. Ask to see the exact consent wording and how it’s recorded with each lead.

When shared leads can make sense

Shared leads aren’t always a mistake. Agencies with dedicated dialers, scripts and the capacity to call within seconds can win enough races to make the numbers work. If that’s not your model, and you want clients who stay on the books and send referrals, exclusive leads are usually the better fit.

How to tell if a lead is really exclusive

  1. Is exclusivity in your agreement, in writing, for the life of the lead?
  2. Will the same person ever be sold again later as an “aged” lead?
  3. Did the client apply to you by name, or to a generic quote site?
  4. Is their phone number verified before you receive it?
  5. Can you see the page and questions the client actually filled out?

How North Advisor Group handles it

Every lead goes to one advisor and is never shared, resold or recycled. Clients apply on the advisor’s own branded portal, are screened for need, timing, budget, insurable age and licensed province, verify their phone number and consent to that advisor’s call. Leads that fail a check are replaced at no cost. You can try a live client portal to see exactly what clients see, or read the North Advisor Group Standard.

Frequently asked questions

Are exclusive insurance leads worth the higher price?

For most advisors who call quickly and run a proper needs analysis, yes. Compare cost per placed policy, not cost per lead. Exclusive leads remove the race against other advisors, which usually lifts contact and appointment rates.

How many advisors get a shared lead?

It depends on the vendor, but shared leads are commonly sold to several advisors at the same time. Ask the vendor for the maximum number of buyers per lead, in writing.

What is an aged insurance lead?

An aged lead is an older request, often weeks or months old, resold at a discount. The person may no longer be shopping or may have already bought coverage.

Can I buy leads from any province in Canada?

You can only write business where you’re licensed, and licences are provincial. Only buy leads from provinces where you hold an active licence.

Want leads that pass every one of these checks?

Exclusive to you, screened for income and intent, contact verified and consented.

Apply to partner See a live client portal

Sources

  1. CRTC: Canada’s Anti-Spam Legislation, requirements for commercial electronic messages
  2. Canadian Council of Insurance Regulators: provincial and territorial regulators
  3. FSRA: Life and accident & sickness licence for agents licensed in another province
  4. Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada: PIPEDA

General information for licensed advisors, not legal or compliance advice. Check the rules for your licence with your provincial regulator and your MGA or carrier.