Home / For advisors / Guides / Speed to lead
How fast should you call an insurance lead? Speed to lead and follow-up for advisors
Why speed decides most leads
Someone who just asked about life or disability coverage is thinking about it right now. An hour later they’re back at work, picking up kids or talking to another advisor. Harvard Business Review’s 2011 research on online leads found that firms trying to reach a lead within an hour were nearly seven times as likely to have a meaningful conversation as firms that waited even an hour longer, and far more likely than firms that waited a day. The same research found many companies took far longer than an hour to respond.
With shared leads, speed is a race against other advisors. With exclusive leads there’s no race, but interest still cools fast. Either way, the first minutes matter most.
What to send before you call
Send a short text and email within a minute of the application, in your name, confirming you’ll call. It does two jobs: they recognize your number when it rings, and they know a real advisor is coming.
Hi Sarah, it’s Daniel Reyes. Thanks for your request. I’ll call you in the next few minutes from this number to go over your options.
Under CASL, commercial texts and emails need consent, must identify you and must include a way to unsubscribe. Keep the confirmation short and factual.
How to open the first call
- Reference what they asked for. “You asked about protecting your income if you can’t work.”
- Confirm the basics. Who depends on them, what they have now through work, and their timing.
- Set the agenda. Explain you’ll do a short needs analysis, then show options that fit their budget.
- Book the next step before you hang up. If you can’t do the needs analysis now, book a time while they’re on the phone.
Use what they told you on the application. “My family” usually points to term life. “My income” points to disability or income protection, especially for the self-employed. “All of it” is a living benefits conversation: life, disability and critical illness together.
A 7-day follow-up cadence
| When | What to do |
|---|---|
| Minute 0–1 | Automatic confirmation text and email in your name |
| Minute 1–5 | First call. If no answer, leave a short voicemail |
| Within the hour | Second call |
| Day 1 | Call morning and late afternoon, plus one text |
| Day 2–3 | One call a day at a different time |
| Day 5 | Call and email with a simple “still want to look at options?” |
| Day 7 | Final call and text, then move to a longer-term nurture |
Most advisors give up after one or two attempts. Persistence over the first week, at varied times, is where a lot of appointments come from. Stop immediately if someone asks you to.
What to track every week
- Speed to first call: minutes from application to your first dial.
- Contact rate: leads you actually spoke with.
- Appointment rate: contacts who booked a needs analysis.
- App rate and placement rate: appointments that became apps, and apps placed in force.
If contact rate is low, look at speed and persistence. If appointment rate is low, look at your first-call opening. If placement is low, look at needs analysis and underwriting fit.
How North Advisor Group helps
Every lead reaches your phone, email, CRM and lead dashboard in real time, with a score, an AI summary and which product to lead with. Within a minute, the client gets a text and email in your name confirming your call, so when you dial, they’re expecting you.
Frequently asked questions
How quickly should I call a new insurance lead?
Within 5 minutes if you can, and within the hour at the latest. Research published in Harvard Business Review found that contacting online leads within an hour made a meaningful conversation far more likely than waiting even an hour longer.
How many times should I call an insurance lead?
Plan on several attempts over the first 7 days at different times of day, with texts and emails in between, unless the person asks you to stop.
Should I text a lead before calling?
Yes. A short confirmation text in your name helps them recognize your number. Make sure your texts meet CASL requirements: consent, identification and a way to unsubscribe.
What should I say on the first call with an insurance lead?
Reference what they asked for, confirm who depends on them and their timing, explain you’ll do a short needs analysis, and book the next step before you hang up.
Want leads that pass every one of these checks?
Exclusive to you, screened for income and intent, contact verified and consented.
Apply to partner See a live client portal